The New York Yankees are confronting difficult roster decisions as several key players struggle, despite the team's strong 43-27 start to the 2026 season.
Manager Aaron Boone and General Manager Brian Cashman face pressure to decide whether to stick with underperforming contributors or seek upgrades before the trade deadline.
Shortstop Dilemma
Shortstop Anthony Volpe has struggled at the plate since returning from left shoulder surgery. He owns a career .
222 batting average and . 660 OPS over 494 games.
This season, Volpe has only five extra-base hits in 82 at-bats, with a . 317 on-base percentage that limits his speed on the bases.
In contrast, backup infielder Jose Caballero has emerged as a viable alternative. He has posted a .
715 OPS and recorded five defensive runs saved.
MLB.
com reporter Bryan Hoch noted that the Yankees originally expected Caballero to be a temporary replacement at shortstop before handing the role back to Volpe.
However, Caballero's glovework has sparked debate within the organization about the best way to prevent runs.
Other Underperformers
Catcher Austin Wells has disappointed, batting just . 166 before landing on the injured list.
Reliever Jake Bird has become a liability in the bullpen, posting a 1.429 WHIP due to poor pitch command.
Designated hitter Giancarlo Stanton recently aggravated a calf injury, adding to frustration over his inability to stay healthy.
The Yankees must now weigh these struggles as they consider potential moves to strengthen the roster.
