Babcock's coaching style is known for discipline, intensity, and structure. This raises questions about his fit with star players like Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl.
During his time in Toronto, he favored two-way wingers such as Hyman and Connor Brown and carefully balanced offensive lines.
There is speculation about his approach to managing young talent and goalie deployment. Babcock previously named Jonathan Bernier as the starting goalie with shared duties.
He may similarly manage Frederik Andersen and Tristan Jarry in Edmonton.
Critics remain cautious due to past allegations of bullying and controversial tactics. However, insiders note a potential adjustment in his approach.
As reported, "He never did anything bad enough to warrant the NHL boycotting his employment forever… He'll have finally realized that this isn't the time or place to go full bully Babcock."
Questions also surround how the Oilers' leadership group will respond if Babcock pushes boundaries. Key players are reportedly open to being held accountable but unwilling to tolerate disrespect.
Despite external skepticism, there is internal confidence that McDavid will not oppose the hire.
"The narrative that the Oilers going out and hiring Babcock will somehow push McDavid to the brink and lead to a trade request is ridiculous," according to sources familiar with the team.
Pressure on Babcock is already mounting, with public speculation about his job security even before the season begins.
>>> John Cena Reveals Details of Two Hair Transplant Surgeries at Comic-Con
The intensity of the Canadian market means any early struggles could quickly escalate scrutiny on his coaching.