The polarization of the panel highlights the unique narrative of the season: a contrast between Arsenal's collective machine and Manchester United's individual brilliance.
For some, the choice came down to the pure momentum that carried the North London side through their early structural tests.
"With Arsenal finally getting over the line, Rice edges it," observed Yara El-Shaboury, Football Writer.
The discussion extended far beyond the traditional heavyweights.
Across the league, individual quality flourished in unexpected environments, providing a reminder that the top flight's depth stretches well beyond the top three positions.
Breakthrough stars and clinical finishers from mid-table sides forced their way into the conversation. "Antoine Semenyo," wrote Ben Fisher, Football Writer.
"Phenomenal for Bournemouth and superb for Manchester City."
Yet, the romantic allure of a talismanic figure dragging an otherwise dysfunctional team forward remained incredibly potent for many writers.
That kept Manchester United's creative hub at the center of the debate.
"Fernandes," asserted Taha Hashim, Football Writer. "Manchester United's best player for six and a half years, bringing colour to their gloomiest days."
For the tactical purists, however, the individual accolades could not be separated from the collective system that secured the ultimate prize.
The focus inevitably shifted back to the core components of the champion's blueprint.
"Rice," argued Andy Hunter, Football Writer.
"Given the importance of set pieces and defensive organisation to the destination of the title, it has to be the player who was key to both for the champions."
Ultimately, the beauty of the season lay in the eye of the beholder.
